Is Robotic Knee Replacement Really Better? What the RASKAL Trial Reveals About the Future of Knee Surgery

The Joint Replacement Podcast — Episode #70

By Matthew Sloan, MD | Orthopedic Surgeon & Director of Robotics, Emerson Health

Does robotic knee replacement actually lead to better outcomes? And have orthopedic surgeons been making a mistake by trying to align every knee perfectly straight?

These are two of the most important questions facing modern knee replacement surgery.

For decades, surgeons have focused on restoring a straight mechanical axis, creating balanced ligaments, and positioning implants as accurately as possible. But the growing adoption of robotic technology is challenging some of our traditional assumptions.

In Episode #70 of The Joint Replacement Podcast, I sat down with Professor Sam MacDessi, MD, an internationally recognized knee replacement surgeon from Sydney, Australia.

Dr. MacDessi developed the Coronal Plane Alignment of the Knee (CPAK) classification system and helped lead the landmark RASKAL randomized controlled trial, which examined two fundamental questions:

  1. Does robotic-assisted knee replacement produce better outcomes than computer-navigated knee replacement?
  2. Does personalized, functional knee alignment produce better outcomes than traditional mechanical alignment?

The results were fascinating, and in some ways surprising.

Perhaps most interestingly, Dr. MacDessi began his research as a skeptic of robotic surgery. Today, he routinely performs robotic knee replacements and believes conventional instrumentation may eventually become obsolete.

Here’s what we discussed and what patients should understand.

1. Does Robotic Knee Replacement Actually Improve Patient Outcomes?

One of the most important findings from the RASKAL trial was that robotic knee replacement did not demonstrate superior patient-reported outcomes compared with computer-navigated knee replacement at two years.

The trial enrolled 303 patients and compared robotic-assisted surgery with computer-assisted navigation, alongside two different alignment philosophies.

Researchers evaluated multiple measures of recovery, including:

  • Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS-12)
  • Forgotten Joint Score
  • Patient satisfaction
  • Pain and general health
  • Clinically meaningful improvement

Across these patient-reported measures, the investigators did not identify significant differences between the technology groups.

But there is an important distinction.

The study compared robotic surgery against computer-navigated surgery, not conventional manual instrumentation.

Computer navigation already provides surgeons with highly accurate measurements and guidance for implant positioning.

This means the RASKAL trial was comparing two advanced surgical technologies rather than simply comparing a robot with traditional knee replacement.

And although the patient-reported outcomes were similar, the technologies were not identical in their surgical performance.

2. The Robot Was Faster and Better at Preserving Soft Tissues

Despite similar patient-reported outcomes, robotic surgery demonstrated several technical advantages.

In the RASKAL trial, robotic-assisted knee replacement was approximately 11 minutes faster than computer-navigated surgery.

This finding may surprise patients who have heard that robotic surgery takes longer.

However, the comparison matters. Traditional computer navigation often requires more cumbersome registration, instrumentation, adjustments, and repeated bone cuts.

Modern robotic systems streamline the planning and execution process.

The RASKAL investigators also found better preservation of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) with robotic surgery.

This ligament contributes to knee stability and function, particularly in cruciate-retaining knee replacement designs.

Robotic systems can constrain the saw blade within predefined boundaries, potentially reducing unintended injury to surrounding structures.

Participating surgeons also overwhelmingly preferred the robotic system, reporting that it was easier and less stressful to use.

The key finding: More precise surgery and better technical execution do not automatically translate into measurable improvements in patient-reported outcomes over the first two years.

That raises an important question.

Are our surgical technologies improving faster than our ability to measure their benefits?

3. Have We Been Aligning Knee Replacements Wrong for Decades?

Historically, total knee replacement has been performed using a philosophy called mechanical alignment.

The basic idea is straightforward: position the implants so the mechanical axis of the leg is straight and the load is distributed across the replacement.

Mechanical alignment has an excellent track record, with many implants surviving 20 years or longer.

But there is a problem.

Not everyone is born with perfectly straight legs.

Some patients naturally have bowlegged alignment, while others have varying degrees of knock-kneed alignment.

Their joint lines, ligament tension, and bone anatomy are different.

When we attempt to make every knee perfectly straight, we may move some patients significantly away from their natural anatomy.

That can create abnormal ligament tension and require extensive surgical releases to make the knee feel balanced.

Dr. MacDessi explained that mechanical alignment is not necessarily wrong. Rather, it may not be the ideal solution for every patient.

This is where personalized knee replacement becomes important.

4. What Is CPAK, and Why Does It Matter?

Dr. MacDessi helped develop the Coronal Plane Alignment of the Knee (CPAK) classification to better describe the natural variation in knee anatomy.

Published in 2021, CPAK divides knees into nine phenotypes based on two important measurements:

Arithmetic hip-knee-ankle angle (aHKA): An estimate of the patient’s constitutional limb alignment.

Joint line obliquity (JLO): The orientation of the knee joint line relative to the limb.

Together, these measurements help describe whether a patient’s knee naturally has varus, neutral, or valgus alignment and how the joint line is oriented.

The classification provides a common language for surgeons and researchers studying knee alignment.

For example, a patient with a constitutional varus knee may experience substantially different ligament tension if their knee replacement is placed into a completely neutral mechanical alignment.

Dr. MacDessi emphasized that CPAK is primarily a classification and research tool, not a prescription for how every knee should be reconstructed.

The larger goal is understanding how much we should change a patient’s anatomy during surgery.

5. Personalized Alignment Dramatically Reduced Ligament Releases

One of the most striking findings from the RASKAL trial involved the need for ligament releases.

In traditional mechanical alignment, surgeons sometimes need to release portions of tight ligaments to balance the knee after positioning the implants.

Functional alignment takes a different approach.

Instead of forcing every knee into the same alignment, the surgeon attempts to preserve more of the patient’s natural anatomy while achieving appropriate stability and ligament balance.

In RASKAL, the difference in ligament releases was substantial:

Surgical alignmentPatients requiring a soft-tissue release
Mechanical alignment44%
Functional alignment8%

Functional alignment reduced the frequency of ligament releases from 44% to 8%.

That’s a remarkable technical difference.

Preserving native soft tissues may have advantages for surgical efficiency and ligament function.

However, despite this large reduction in releases, patients in the functional alignment group did not demonstrate significantly better patient-reported outcomes at two years.

The long-term clinical significance of fewer ligament releases remains an important area of investigation.

6. Do We Actually Know What a Perfectly Balanced Knee Is?

This was one of my favorite parts of our conversation.

In robotic knee replacement, we now have technology capable of measuring implant alignment, joint gaps, and ligament laxity with extraordinary precision.

But there’s an uncomfortable reality.

We still don’t know the ideal ligament balance for every patient.

Surgeons frequently describe a well-balanced knee as having relatively small and symmetric gaps.

Yet when we measure patients’ native knees before performing bone cuts, we find tremendous variability.

Some knees naturally have greater lateral laxity. Others are relatively symmetric. Ligament tension also changes throughout flexion and extension.

Why should we assume that every knee replacement should have exactly the same amount of laxity?

Dr. MacDessi explained that although robotic systems are outstanding measurement tools, surgeons are still working to understand which measurements produce the best function.

This may be one of the next major advances in personalized knee replacement.

The future may involve restoring each patient’s natural balance rather than making every knee conform to a standardized numerical target.

7. If Outcomes Are Similar, Why Would a Leading Researcher Choose Robotics for His Own Mother?

Perhaps the most memorable moment of the interview came when we discussed whether conventional knee replacement instruments would disappear in the future.

Dr. MacDessi made a particularly revealing statement:

“If my mum was to have a knee replacement, I’d want it done robotically.”

This is especially interesting coming from a surgeon who helped conduct a randomized trial demonstrating similar patient-reported outcomes between robotic and computer-navigated surgery.

His reasoning centered on precision, consistency, and the ability to execute a surgical plan reliably.

He explained that even experienced surgeons can occasionally produce implant positioning they wish had been slightly different.

Robotic technology offers tools that can reduce some of that variability.

It also allows surgeons to measure anatomy, evaluate ligament balance, virtually adjust implant positioning, and perform precisely planned bone resections.

Dr. MacDessi believes these capabilities are critical for the next generation of knee replacement techniques.

However, his personal preference should not be confused with evidence that robotics consistently produces better clinical outcomes for every patient.

That distinction matters.

8. Will Manual Knee Replacement Disappear in Five Years?

Dr. MacDessi believes conventional knee replacement instrumentation will become increasingly uncommon as robotic systems become more widely available.

In Australia, he noted that more than half of knee replacements were already being performed with robotic assistance.

He expects adoption to continue increasing.

His argument is that once surgeons become comfortable having detailed real-time information about implant positioning, bone resections, and ligament balance, it becomes difficult to return to techniques without that information.

But challenges remain.

Robotic systems require significant capital investment, equipment, training, and ongoing costs.

And existing randomized trials have not established that robotic surgery consistently provides better patient-reported outcomes than high-quality computer-assisted techniques over the first one or two years.

For hospitals, the financial justification remains an important consideration.

Longer-term research examining implant survivorship, revision rates, complications, and cost-effectiveness may help answer these questions.

My interpretation is that robotics is likely to become increasingly common, but the evidence does not yet justify declaring conventional knee replacement obsolete.

9. Can Cementless Knee Replacement Work in Older Patients?

We also discussed another evolving area of knee replacement surgery: cementless fixation.

Traditionally, cemented implants have been favored for many older patients because of concerns about bone quality.

Dr. MacDessi explained that his approach has changed considerably in recent years.

He now frequently uses cementless, cruciate-retaining implants, including in selected older patients, based on intraoperative bone quality and the stability of the reconstruction.

He believes robotic precision, accurate implant sizing, preservation of native bone anatomy, and functional alignment may help support cementless fixation.

However, the decision between cemented and cementless implants remains individualized.

Bone quality, implant design, age, activity level, and other patient characteristics all matter.

Registry findings have also raised concerns about early fixation problems in some older patient groups receiving cementless knee replacement.

Therefore, cementless fixation should not automatically be considered superior, especially in elderly patients or those with compromised bone quality.

As Dr. MacDessi explained, if fixation is uncertain, cementing remains a reasonable choice.

10. The Future of Knee Replacement Is About More Than Just Making the Leg Straight

One of the central themes throughout our conversation was that knee replacement involves much more than alignment in a single plane.

The knee is a complex three-dimensional joint.

Surgeons must consider:

  • Coronal alignment: Whether the leg is relatively straight, bowlegged, or knock-kneed
  • Sagittal alignment: Tibial slope and the relationship between the femur and tibia
  • Rotational alignment: How the implants rotate relative to the bones
  • Ligament balance: How stability changes throughout knee motion
  • Patellofemoral mechanics: How the kneecap tracks and interacts with the replacement

Dr. MacDessi believes understanding these additional dimensions will be critical to advancing personalized knee replacement.

In particular, he is interested in developing new frameworks for sagittal alignment and improving the restoration of native knee mechanics.

Perhaps the most exciting use of robotic technology isn’t simply placing implants more accurately.

It may be helping us discover where the implants should actually go for each individual patient.

What Does This Mean for Patients Considering Knee Replacement?

For patients, the most important takeaway is that technology alone does not determine surgical success.

Robotic knee replacement offers sophisticated planning, measurement, and execution capabilities.

But current randomized evidence does not demonstrate that every patient undergoing robotic-assisted surgery will experience less pain, faster recovery, or better function than a patient receiving a well-performed replacement using another technique.

Surgeon experience, appropriate patient selection, thoughtful implant positioning, soft-tissue management, and postoperative care remain essential.

When choosing a knee replacement surgeon, I encourage patients to ask:

  1. How many knee replacements do you perform each year?
  2. What is your experience with the technique you recommend?
  3. How do you determine the appropriate alignment for my knee?
  4. How do you assess ligament balance during surgery?
  5. What are your patient-reported outcomes and complication rates?

The goal should not simply be to find a surgeon who uses the newest technology.

The goal is to find an experienced surgeon who understands your anatomy, can explain their surgical approach, and consistently achieves excellent outcomes.

Final Thoughts: Precision Is Important, but We Still Need to Define the Target

The RASKAL trial provides an important contribution to our understanding of robotic knee replacement and personalized alignment.

It demonstrates that robotic technology can improve certain aspects of surgical execution without necessarily producing measurable improvements in patient-reported outcomes over two years.

It also shows that personalized alignment can dramatically reduce the need for ligament releases without establishing short-term superiority in patient-reported recovery.

To me, these findings don’t mean that robotic technology is unimportant.

They mean we have more work to do.

We now have incredibly precise tools for measuring and performing knee replacement surgery.

The next challenge is determining exactly how to use that precision to improve outcomes for individual patients.

That may ultimately be the most important contribution of robotics to orthopedic surgery.


Watch or Listen to Episode #70

#70 – Is Robotic Knee Replacement Really Better? Sam MacDessi, MD

Join me and Professor Sam MacDessi for a detailed discussion of the RASKAL trial, CPAK classification, robotic technology, personalized knee alignment, cementless implants, and the future of total knee replacement.

🎙️ Watch on YouTube: The Joint Replacement Podcast

🎧 Listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts: Visit The Joint Replacement Podcast

Get More Evidence-Based Joint Health Information

Want to stay active, protect your joints, and understand the latest research on hip and knee replacement?

Subscribe to my free weekly newsletter, Strong Joints, Strong Body.

Subscribe to Strong Joints, Strong Body

New articles and conversations cover joint replacement, arthritis treatments, recovery, exercise, longevity, and staying healthy after 50.

About the author: Matthew Sloan, MD, is a board-certified orthopedic surgeon and Director of Robotics for Orthopedics at Emerson Health in Concord, Massachusetts. He specializes in robotic-assisted hip and knee replacement and hosts The Joint Replacement Podcast, featuring conversations with leading orthopedic surgeons and researchers from around the world.

Medical disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized medical advice. Treatment decisions should be made in consultation with your orthopedic surgeon.